Tennessee Williams's Cat On a Hot Tin Roof


In 2013 another revival of Tennessee Williams's Cat On a Hot Tin Roof, starring Scarlett Johansson opened at the Richard Rodgers theatre on Broadway. This was the revival's website.
Content is from the site's 2013 archived pages and other outside sources.

“POWERFUL. SCARLETT JOHANSSON delivers the goods as an EXCEPTIONALLY FINE stage actress. This is an INTELLIGENT, METICULOUSLY CRAFTED, FULLY COMMITTED performance by an actress who RADIATES SOME KIND OF LIFE FORCE – and shimmering sexuality – without even trying. She generates enough heat to keep the Tri-State toasty through the winter.

BENJAMIN WALKER is EXCELLENT, with a charm that belies blazing intensity. ROB ASHFORD and TENNESSEE WILLIAMS’ stage poetry are in sync, making this THE MOST SATISFYING PRODUCTION I’VE SEEN.”



–New York Post


-Financial Times



“A boisterous production that taps into the play’s POWER AND POETRY.”



–Financial Times

“One of the SEXIEST, MOST RIVETING American plays ever written.”





–USA Today




–Bloomberg News


–The New York Times


"I got tickets to opening night as a result of winning the Batman raffle at the South Street fair. MoonAtMidnight.com, the premiere Batman t shirt online store sponsored the event to show off their new collection of sublimated Batman t shirt prints, which are exquisitely awesome. If you're into Batman, you should visit this site just to see the amazing technology behind the new t shirt collection. The site also has a lot of trivia on Batman including a lot of information on Batman's arch enemies, some of which are also on their t shirts. Cat On A Hot Tin Roof is a performance that really delivered the goods - Scarlett Johansson is fantastic in this role, as if it were written especially for her. Sometimes opening night on Broadway is fraught with errors and miscues, but if that happened, I was totally unaware - the performance seemed perfect, compelling and I left the theater blown away with the last scene still playing in my mind, and it's so powerful I know I'll remember it forever. You must see this show before it changes players! I love the fact that I lucked into it due to a Batman event - it all makes perfect sense!" Rita Lowe



at the

226 West 46th Street, New York
between Broadway and 8th Avenue


Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

The most hotly anticipated event of the Broadway season.

Tony Award® winner Scarlett Johansson (A View From the BridgeLost in Translation) returns to Broadway as "Maggie the Cat" in Tennessee Williams' Pulitzer Prize-winning drama, Cat on a Hot Tin RoofCiarán Hinds("Political Animals," There Will Be Blood), Benjamin Walker (Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson) and Tony and Emmy® winner Debra Monk (Curtains, "Damages") co-star in Williams’ classic story about a wealthy Southern family and the passions and secrets that come close to destroying them.

On the eve of his 65th birthday, "Big Daddy" Pollitt, the richest cotton planter in the Mississippi Delta, is distressed by the rocky relationship between his beloved son Brick, an aging football hero who has turned to drink, and Brick’s beautiful and feisty wife Maggie. As the hot summer evening unfolds, the veneer of Southern gentility slips away revealing unpleasant truths as greed, lies and suppressed sexuality reach a boiling point.

Tony and Emmy winner Rob Ashford, fresh from his recent Olivier-winning West End production of Anna Christie, directs this stunning, must-see new production.



January 28, 2013 – Broadway.com

INTERVIEWS By Ryan Gilbert January 28, 2013

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof Star Benjamin Walker on Co-Starring with the 'Fantastic' Scarlett Johansson, Acting in a Towel & More

After earning the nickname “Sexypants” as our seventh commander-in-chief in the outrageous rock musical Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson, Benjamin Walker delivered a heroic performance as yet another president onscreen in Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter. But luckily for Broadway audiences, this theater vet didn't stay away from the stage for long: Walker is co-starring with Tony winner Scarlett Johansson in the latest revival of Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Tennessee Williams’ Southern-soaked American classic. Walker plays Brick Pollitt, the despondent, hard-drinking former golden boy grieving for his high school pal and fending off the advances of his sexy wife, Maggie. Broadway.com recently chatted with Walker about getting intimate with Johansson, being clad in only a towel night after night and what happened to “Ghost Skipper.”

How familiar were you with Cat on a Hot Tin Roofbefore you signed on to the production?
I studied it in [Juilliard] but I hadn’t read it in a few years, and I hadn’t seen the movie since I was a kid. I hadn’t seen a production of it other than people working on it at school, and I think it’s been very helpful that I came in with fresh eyes. It was nice to come with a blank slate.

What made you want to be a part of this revival?
Rob Ashford and Scarlett Johansson. With those two, the play could have been toilet paper and I would have been interested.

You and Scarlett have to establish such a complex and intimate connection early on in the play. What has it been like working with her?
We talk about that connection every day. Brick and Maggie have a very complicated relationship, but I think every love relationship has those layers. Luckily, we have the brilliant poetry of Tennessee Williams to shepherd us through it. Scarlett is fantastic. She’s highly intelligent, very funny and a wonderful scene partner. Maggie has this great line, “I've gone through this – hideous! – transformation, become – hard!” Scarlett is courageous enough to allow herself to drift from being attractive to find that place in herself that is desperate, and what’s ironic is that it just makes her more attractive. I think she’s fearless. The woman’s got a Tony, she could do movies in Hollywood until she’s blue in the face, but for some reason she’s back here trying to tackle one of the most difficult parts written for a woman her age. I have to hand it to her.

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof is a play about sex, lies, greed and alcohol addiction. How do you relate to these characters?
Well, that’s what I think is great about Tennessee Williams. The play continues to hold up. These are issues that we all struggle with all the time.

The role of Brick, on paper, seems like a reactive part and challenging to pull off. Is it a thankless part?
That has not occurred to me. But, you know, the play is called Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, it’s not called Brick on a Hot Tin Roof [laughs]. That ought to tip you off right there, but I have Tennessee Williams’ text. There’s no stone unturned, and if you pay attention to what he wrote, in the dialogue and in his essays about it, it never occurred to me that Brick is a thankless part.

So much is required of you physically in this role. The play is almost three hours long, and you’re hopping around on crutches and drinking throughout. How do you do it each night?
It’s exhausting, particularly now that it’s so cold outside. I have to take care of myself and keep myself healthy. I have a wonderful group of actors around me that really helps me sustain it, particularly Ciaran Hinds [Big Daddy]. You can be as exhausted as any human being on the planet, and as soon as you lock eyes with him, it’s the 50s, your name is Brick and you’re in Mississippi whether you like it or not.

Are you sick yet of being asked about being shirtless and only wearing a towel?
[Laughs] No! People haven’t asked me about it as much as you’d think.

What about the New York Magazine review that was almost exclusively about the towel?
What? You’re kidding. It better be a good review! Being in shape is the least you have to do for the job.

Do you have a strong opinion about what the relationship between Brick and Skipper was?

What can you tell us about it?
Not really anything, and I’ll tell you why. Those private things, for me as an actor and for each individual audience member, need to stay private. That’s what’s great about the play. Everybody comes in, and they have to figure it out themselves. If I tell you and you print it, then that takes the fun out of it. You have an opinion of what you think happened, but if I tell you then you’re going to compare what you felt to what I thought and it’s all screwed up. Where’s the fun in that? If a magician tells you how he did his trick, it’s not magical any more.

Why do you think the 1958 movie smoothed over that relationship?
They made that movie for a specific time for a specific group of actors. You can’t judge someone else’s work, but you don’t have to agree with it every time.

Early previews of Cat on a Hot Tin Roof featured Jordan Dean portraying “Ghost Skipper,” but that role has since been eliminated. Has that changed the dynamic?
Well, of course, we all miss having Jordan Dean around. But it has changed it because, healthy or unhealthy, it was a nice safety net to have somebody there as Skipper. And now that he’s gone, it almost made it worse because we all really feel a literal absence, which we would have anyway, but it’s just an extra bit of sadness that enriches everyone’s work. From the beginning, Rob was open with this [being] an idea we’d like to try as an experiment in understanding the play better and in getting everyone on the same page with who Skipper might be. We had very thorough discussions.

You’re married to Mamie Gummer, the daughter of Meryl Streep. Do you feel like you’ve had to become a more private person by marrying into a such a famous family?
It is interesting: People ask about my mother-in-law but they don’t ask about my mom! I find that hugely offensive [laughs]. I get it. I have the luxury to be surrounded by wonderful, highly intelligent and talented women. You’re not going to hear me complain about the side effects of it.

What is coming up next for you?
I’d like to do more theater. Tell somebody to call me up and give me an offer. I wouldn’t mind doing a little more singing and dancing, but I’m happy with health insurance. Do you have any ideas? I’ll definitely be doing some stand-up. We’re going to kick Find The Funny into high gear at Joe’s Pub. We’ve taken a little hiatus so I could focus on this, but we’ll get back to that shortly.




January 13, 2013 – CBSNews.com

Q&A: Scarlett Johansson

CBS News) Scarlett Johansson built a loyal following with roles in movies like 2003's "Lost in Translation," where she starred opposite Bill Murray. The question now is whether all those movie fans will follow her to the Broadway theater. That's where Anthony Mason caught up with her for some Questions and Answers:

Beating up bad guys last summer as the Black Widow was part of a career transition for one of Hollywood's greatest sex symbols. The next step will take Scarlett Johansson from the sound stage to the Broadway stage:

"Sometimes you wander around the theater to think?" Mason asked.

"Well, I like to be on the stage when there's nobody out there," she replied.

For the next two-and-a-half months she'll be at the Richard Rodgers Theatre. "It's a beautiful theater," Johansson said. "You know, I don't really spend a lot of time in the house. I like to be up there."

Scarlett Johansson stars a Maggie in a revival of Tennessee Williams' "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof."  / CBS News

The 28-year-old actress is taking on one of theatre's classic roles: Maggie in Tennessee Williams' "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof."

"Even after I was committed to doing it, it weighed on me like a ball and chain," Johansson said. She said what attracted her to the part was "that it was terrifyingly challenging, and I didn't know how to do it."

But eager to move beyond the ingenue roles that made her a movie star, Johansson has taken on the part of an ambitious Southern belle trying to hold onto her decaying marriage.

"It is intense. But it's liberating."

Johansson reportedly is earning $40,000 a week plus a percentage of the box office - which means the show needs to sell a lot of tickets.

Johansson read the sign in the lobby: "This performance is sold out. But unfortunately, it's facing us."

"What's it say on the other side?" Mason asked.

"Yeah, it's like free tickets."

Even in previews, her name on the marquee has made "Cat" one of the hottest tickets on Broadway.

"Your fame means that your name has been reduced to acronym that everybody uses."

"That's terrible," she laughed. "It's so terrible. I hate that name. It's so crazy."

"Does anybody call you ScarJo at home?" Mason asked.

"No! No. Hopefully it's gonna go away sometime."

This is not Johansson's first appearance on Broadway. In 2010 she won a Tony Award for her performance in Arthur Miller's "A View From the Bridge."

"I read that after that play you said to yourself, 'I'm not going to do another play,'" Mason said.

"I think it's kind of what I imagine it must be like to give childbirth, and you sort of forget all the pain," she laughed. "You just remember this beautiful prize you hold."






    Two-time Pulitzer Prize-winning writer Tennessee Williams is one of America's greatest playwrights. His plays include The Glass Menagerie, A Streetcar Named Desire and The Night of the Iguana among other celebrated works. In addition to twenty-five full-length plays, Williams produced dozens of short plays and screenplays, two novels, a novella, sixty short stories, over one hundred poems, and an autobiography. His works have been translated into at least twenty-seven languages, and countless productions of his work have been staged around the world.

  • ROB ASHFORD (Director)

    Rob Ashford is an American director and choreographer who works extensively on Broadway and in London's West End. As an Associate Director for London's Donmar Warehouse, Rob's productions include Anna Christie starring Jude Law and Ruth Wilson (Olivier Award for Best Revival), A Streetcar Named Desire starring Rachel Weisz (Olivier nomination) and Parade (Olivier nominations for Direction and Choreography). In New York, he is currently represented by Evita for which he provided the choreography (Tony, Drama Desk, Outer Critics Circle, Astaire nominations). He directed and choreographed How to Succeed in Business starring Daniel Radcliffe (Tony nominations for Direction and Choreography) and Promises, Promises starring Sean Hayes and Kristen Chenowith (Tony nomination for Choreography). He choreographed Cry Baby (Drama Desk, Outer Critics and Astaire Awards, Tony nomination), Curtains (Tony nomination), The Wedding Singer (Tony nomination), and Thoroughly Modern Millie (Tony Award for Best Choreography). Other London credits include Shrek (Co Director), Evita (Olivier nomination), Guys and Dolls (Olivier nomination), Thoroughly Modern Millie (Olivier nomination), and Forum (National Theatre). He recently directed the World Premier of the new musical Finding Wonderland produced by Harvey Weinstein at The Curve Theatre in Leicester. He choreographed Candide which played at The ENO in London, La Scala in Milan, and The Chatelet in Paris. He won an Emmy Award for his choreography for the 81st Academy Awards and has staged tributes for Meryl Streep, Barbara Cook, Jerry Herman, Barbra Streisand and Andrew Lloyd Webber for The Kennedy Center Honors. He did the choreography for the film Beyond the Sea directed by and starring Kevin Spacey. He is on The Board of Trustees for The Joyce Theatre, The Executive Board of SDC, and is an Associate Director of The Old Vic in London.

  • CHRISTOPHER ORAM (Scenic Designer)

    Recipient of Tony, Olivier, Evening Standard, Critics Circle, Garland and Ovation awards for his work both here in the U.S. and in the U.K. His most recent work on Broadway includes the scenic and costume designs for Evita and the Donmar Warehouse productions of RedHamlet with Jude Law and Frost/Nixon. Also, King Lear with Derek Jacobi (BAM).

  • JULIE WEISS (Costume Design)

    Broadway: The Elephant Man (Tony nom.), PiafMacbeth. TV: “The Dollmaker” (Emmy Award), “Little Gloria…Happy at Last” (Emmy nom.), “Evergreen” (Emmy nom.), “Mrs. Harris” (Emmy nom.), “A Woman of Independent Means” (Emmy Award). Film: American Beauty (Costume Designers Guild Award), Fear and Loathing in Las VegasSteel MagnoliasF/XHollywoodlandSearching for Bobby FischerHoneymoon in VegasA Simple PlanGet LowTwelve Monkeys (Academy Award nom.), The RingFrida (Academy Award nom.), BobbyAuto FocusSecretariat (Diane Lane), No Strings AttachedBlades of Glory (Costume Designers Guild Award), HBO’s Criminal JusticeHitchcock. Julie was also the recipient of the Costume Designers Guild’s award for career achievement.

  • NEIL AUSTIN (Lighting Designer)

    Recipient of the 2010 Tony and Drama Desk Awards for Red and the 2011 Laurence Olivier Award for The White Guard at the National Theatre, London. Previous Broadway credits include Evita (Marquis), Red(Golden), Hamlet (Broadhurst), The Seafarer (Booth), Frost/Nixon (Jacobs). Other U.S. credits include King Lear with Derek Jacobi and The Seagull and King Lear with Ian McKellen (BAM), Red and Parade (Taper Forum, Los Angeles), Madame Butterfly (Houston Grand Opera), Frost/Nixon (U.S. national tour). Previously with Rob Ashford: Finding Neverland (Leicester), A Streetcar Named Desire and Parade (Donmar Warehouse). Other theatre: extensive credits in the U.K. for the National Theatre, Donmar Warehouse, Royal Opera House, Royal Shakespeare Company and in the West End.

  • ADAM CORK (Composer and Sound Design)

    Adam Cork is the co-lyricist and composer of the documentary musical London Road (National Theatre Olivier, Critics’ Circle Award, Best Musical 2011). Other work includes Anna Christie (Donmar, Evening Standard Award 2011); King Lear (Donmar, Olivier Award 2011); Red (Donmar/Broadway, Tony Award 2010); Enron (Tony nominations 2010 for Best Score and Best Sound); Romeo and Juliet (RSC/Armory 2010-11); Hamlet (Donmar/Broadway 2009); Phedre (NT/Washington); Macbeth (Chichester/Broadway, Tony nomination 2008); Frost/Nixon (Donmar/Broadway 2007); A Streetcar Named DesireThe Chalk GardenOthello(Donmar); The Last Days of Judas Iscariot (Almeida). Screen work includes scores for The Hollow Crown, series titles and Richard II (Neal Street/NBC/WNET/BBC 2012); Macbeth (BBC 2010).

  • PAUL HUNTLEY (Wig and Hair Design)

    London-born Paul Huntley has worked on hundreds of Broadway shows since his 1972 arrival in New York, most memorably the original productions of AmadeusCatsEvitaLes MisérablesSweeney ToddThe Producers and Hairspray. A recipient of Drama Desk and Tony Awards, he has also worked with the some of the most legendary leading ladies of the cinema, ranging from Bette Davis, Mae West, Marlene Dietrich and Vivien Leigh to Jane Fonda, Faye Dunaway, Glenn Close and Jessica Lange. Current shows include War HorseChaplin and Nice Work If You Can Get It.

  • RICK SORDELET (Fight Director)

    Broadway: 56 Broadway shows including The Lion King, Beauty and the Beast, also the National Tours of Beauty and the Beast, and Les Miz. International: 53 First Class productions worldwide: including Ben Hur Live in Rome and European Tour. Opera: Cyrano (starring Placido Domingo) at the Metropolitan Opera, The Royal Opera House and La Scalla, in Milan. Don Carlo directed by Nicholas Hytner at the MET, and Heart of the Soldier, a new Opera at San Francisco Opera. Television: Stunt Coordinator for “Guiding Light” for 12 years. “One Life to Live”. Instructor: Yale School of Drama. Affiliations: Board member for the Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey. Awards: Edith Oliver Award for Sustained Excellence from the Lucille Lortel Off-Broadway League, Jeff Award for Best Fight Direction for Romeo and Juliet at Chicago Shakespeare Theater.

  • ANGELINA AVALLONE (Makeup Design)

    Broadway: Nice Work If You Can Get ItThe Mystery of Edwin DroodChaplinAn Enemy of the PeopleThe Anarchist, ScandalousGolden BoyGolden AgeVenus in FurAnything GoesRock of AgesMemphisOther Desert CitiesThe Best ManThe Addams FamilyThe Importance of Being EarnestLeap of FaithSunday in the Park With GeorgeA Little Night MusicBye Bye BirdieThe Little MermaidThe Color PurpleChitty Chitty Bang BangGypsyYoung FrankensteinThe Light in the Piazza.





Cat on a Hot Tin Roof – review

***/5 /www.theguardian.com

Almost purr-fect … Scarlett Johansson as Maggie the Cat in Cat On a Hot Tin Roof. Photograph: Joan Marcus/AP/Boneau/Bryan-Brown

Does Broadway need another revival of Tennessee Williams's Cat On a Hot Tin Roof, its third in three years? Perhaps not. But when an actor such as Scarlett Johansson gets her claws into a part like Maggie, the Cat gets another life. Sinuous in a beige slip, with head swathed in a marmalade wig, eyes opulently lined in black, Johansson should get plenty of audience members purring. But despite these charms, director Rob Ashford's production is little more than a star vehicle, erratically driven.

With curtains adorned with a pattern of lowering branches and a burst of ominous strings as the house lights dim, the evening promises southern gothic, but devolves into a mix of naturalism and farce. (For some reason Ashford insists on having characters chase each other around and around the bed.) As in the recent revival of Glengarry Glen Ross with Al Pacino, the actors all seem to be inhabiting different plays, to say nothing of different regions. Some actors luxuriate in the Mississippi vowels while others, such as Debra Monk's Big Mama, decline to offer any discernible accent at all.

The play is set, famously, during a muggy evening on the Pollitt plantation in the Mississippi Delta. The occasion is the 65th birthday of Big Daddy (Ciarán Hinds) and while cancer means he likely won't see another, the family has gathered to celebrate. The elder son Gooper, his grasping wife Mae and their five children (whom Maggie refers to memorably as "no-neck monsters", though Ashford has cast rather slim tots) do everything but wrest the plantation deed from Daddy's dying hand. Meanwhile, younger song Brick (Benjamin Walker) consistently ignores the festivities in favour of the depths of a whiskey bottle, even as his wife Maggie (Johansson) urges him to take an interest in his inheritance.

Brick refuses to sleep with Maggie, believing her to be partially responsible for the death of his best friend, Skipper, who may have loved Brick in a more than friendly way. Resisting the charms of Johansson should indicate a bravura performance, but Walker, a rambunctious delight in Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson, seems oddly passive here. Johansson, on the other hand, is very active and sometimes very good. She looks terrific (if there were an award for foundation garments hers would take the trophy) and she has emphasised her natural huskiness to deliver lines in a seductive growl. As in her Broadway debut in A View from the Bridge, she likes to let the audience know how hard she's working and some scenes seem more studied than lived, though she has a very fine last act. But all her feline grace and neat red claws still can't make this revival land on its feet.



Scarlett Johansson in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Richard Rodgers Theatre, New York, review

Audiences will not be disappointed by Scarlett Johansson's return to the stage in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, writes Mark Hughes.

****/5 By Mark Hughes /GMT 18 Jan 2013 / www.telegraph.co.uk

Scarlett Johansson’s performance as Maggie, the lead in Tennessee Williams’s Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, marks her return to the theatre following her widely acclaimed Broadway debut in Arthur Miller’s A View from the Bridge – and she could barely have chosen a more challenging role. The first half-hour of the three-hour play is almost solely reliant on long monologues from Maggie, with only the briefest of interruptions from her husband Brick (Benjamin Walker).

What’s more, comparisons with the most famous incumbent of that character are inevitable. Like Elizabeth Taylor, Johansson is a former child actress who tentatively moved into adult roles before taking the big screen by storm and becoming one of Hollywood’s leading sex symbols. And like Taylor, who was 25 when she took the role of Maggie opposite Paul Newman in the 1958 film, Johansson (28) delivered a charismatic, if at times slightly breathless, performance.

Affecting a very passable Southern accent, her Maggie flits between rage at the fact her husband no longer seems even to like her, and sorrow that she cannot force him to. In between, there are moments of genuine comedy that drew loud laughs and applause. One wonders, though, how her vocal cords will hold up during the 15-week run – at times, she seemed on the verge of losing her famously husky voice.

Benjamin Walker and Scarlett Johansson in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof. ©2012 Joan Marcus

All the play’s action is set in one room: Maggie and Brick’s bedroom. Throughout the three acts, various family members enter, to discuss the play’s intertwined plot threads, including the fact that Brick’s father, Big Daddy, is dying of cancer but does not yet know it, and Brick’s battle with alcoholism, brought on by feelings of guilt over the death of his best friend Skipper. Vital, too, is Brick’s anger towards his wife Maggie.

Mercifully for Johansson, Maggie is barely in the second act, even if the play is slightly less engaging for her absence. Instead it features Brick and his father, engaged in a lengthy discussion, which at times leaves the drama feeling slightly one-note. Although this is compounded by the unchanging set and costumes, the introduction of Irish actor Ciaran Hinds – giving a colossal performance as Big Daddy – certainly helps spice thing up.

Walker is the one actor who remains on stage at all times – albeit often in silence – and his performance as a weary rather than outright disdainful Brick grows more powerful as the play goes on. Other cast members cast give strong showings. Debra Monk is moving and amusing as Big Mama, while the English actress Emily Bergl is fabulously funny as the jealous and bitchy sister-in-law, Mae – there is no sense of the show hanging entirely upon the Hollywood star at the top of the bill.

Even so, it is Johansson – who spends much of the first act of the play dressed in nothing but a slip – whom the audiences will flock to see. And they will not be disappointed.




Cat on a Hot Tin Roof: Theater Review

1/17/2013 by David Rooney / www.hollywoodreporter.com

Scarlett Johansson, Ciaran Hinds, Benjamin Walker and Debra Monk star in Broadway's third revival in a decade of Tennessee Williams' 1955 drama of greed, mendacity and death.

NEW YORK – Somebody spayed the cat. And it wasn’t the hardworking main attraction Scarlett Johansson, who plays Tennessee Williams’ tenacious feline title character in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof. The star and her similarly marooned fellow castmembers are all at the mercy of Rob Ashford, a director out of his depth and reaching for any floatation device he can grab in this sinking Broadway revival, which manages to be both thunderously emphatic and curiously flat.

Choreographer-turned-director Ashford has staged Broadway revivals of the musicals Promises, Promises and How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. His forays into directing drama have been in acclaimed London productions of Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire (with Rachel Weisz) and Eugene O’Neill’s Anna Christie (with Jude Law). But, the reception for those outings notwithstanding, there’s little evidence here that he knows what he’s doing.

Paradoxically, for someone whose theater experience is rooted in dance, Ashford displays a tin ear for the vigorous musicality of Williams’ flavorful dialogue. The actors are directed to shout or mumble, with the production’s cluttered audio wallpaper forcing them to compete against busy sound and music cues. As a result, the humor often doesn’t land and the dramatic peaks tend to fly by unnoticed.

Lest the subtext should breeze over someone’s head, every bit of key dialogue is underlined with a sonic mallet. A mention of glory days on the football field prompts the eerie echo of a cheering crowd. Recollections of more carefree times are underscored with a tinkling "By the Light of the Silvery Moon." Talk of a fateful phone call triggers a ghostly ringing. And when death comes a calling, the field hands are at the ready offstage to spark up a mournful spiritual. The play’s birthday fireworks are used with the bluntness of punctuation, and as for the Act III storm … whoa there! Usually when the heavens rumble and the gauze curtains billow like this, some undead cad is chomping on the neck of a virgin.

According to reports out of previews, Ashford experimented with having a spectral version of Skipper prowl the stage. That device imposed a vivid embodiment of the football buddy whose death haunts former golden boy Brick Pollitt (Benjamin Walker), forcing him to seek refuge in vast quantities of bourbon. Thankfully, the idea was abandoned, though there are few other signs of restraint. It’s clear that Ashford doesn’t trust the play to work without a lot of intrusive directorial flourishes.

Even the set by gifted designer Christopher Oram is heavy-handed, if quite strikingly so in its washed-out Southern decadence. With a tonal palette ranging from beige to gray, this is a cavernous mausoleum, drenched in Neil Austin’s sepulchral lighting and ominous shadows, which pour in through those aforementioned drapes. Got it. We’re in a place of death. And in case the sexual wasteland that defines the union of Maggie (Johansson) and Brick is unclear, their loveless marital bed stands like a monolith, smack in the middle of the stage. Poor Walker is forced to hobble around it on Brick’s broken ankle like a lame greyhound looping the track

For an actor whose experience is primarily in film, Johansson has innate stage presence, as she showed in her Tony-winning turn opposite Liev Schreiber in A View From the Bridge in 2010. She has no trouble playing sultry and looks alluring in Maggie’s iconic slip. Johansson has made some bold choices in the demanding role, aging herself with a coarsened, growling voice, knowing humor and a refusal to soften the character’s abrasive edge. There’s no kitten in her cat. But keeping Maggie’s vulnerability hidden until the final act seems a mistake. Without the underlying wounds she’s just a shrew.

Many actresses in the part use defiant pride as a means of backing up the massive lie that Maggie tells to secure Brick’s claim on his dying father’s estate. Instead Johansson trembles with the terror of exposure. But there’s otherwise insufficient delicacy in her characterization, which overall is the problem with Ashford’s production.

The first act in particular lumbers along, with Walker mostly seeming as uninterested as Brick is in the prolonged assault of seduction and supplication launched by Maggie, the wife he can no longer stand to see or hear. He fires up only momentarily, and then more consistently in Act II. That’s when Brick is forced into a confrontation with his father Big Daddy (Ciaran Hinds), the blowhard Mississippi Delta plantation owner, kept in the dark about his cancer diagnosis. Walker is at his best showing Brick’s furious defensiveness whenever his wife or father picks at the open wound of Skipper’s death and the ambiguities of their relationship.

There are real sparks in the father-son faceoff because Hinds gets the determination and frustration of Big Daddy, a crude man accustomed to buying or bullying his way out of any situation. It’s a cruel irony that the exception is self-destructive Brick, the only member of the family he truly loves. Ashford and his actors do right by this sometimes-neglected aspect of the play, forging a kinship that exists between the two characters contrary to all logic.

Hinds conveys the hardness of Big Daddy, especially in his cold dismissal of his devoted wife Big Mama (Debra Monk). But in a role that can be shattering, Monk’s performance gets lost. Her moments of hurt, bewilderment and anger mostly dissolve in the stormy air or are steamrolled by Ashford’s bag of tricks. As Brick’s vulture-like brother and sister-in-law, Gooper and Mae, Michael Park and Emily Bergl hit the required notes of unctuousness and avarice. But here, too, some of the caustic wit that runs through this play about greed, lies and death is missing, along with the pathos.

Williams’ 1955 Pulitzer winner has not exactly been neglected on Broadway, this being its third revival in a decade. It’s arguable whether this staging hits fewer or more of the right notes than the handsome but unbalanced 2003 production, in which Ashley Judd and Jason Patric were seriously outclassed by Ned Beatty and Margo Martindale in the senior roles. Or the 2008 all-black staging, where Terrence HowardAnika Noni RoseJames Earl Jonesand Phylicia Rashad crackled with life despite the inconsistencies of Debbie Allen’s direction. For an American classic, this is a surprisingly tough work to conquer.

Either way, it’s sad to think that audiences experiencing the play for the first time in this laborious version might be inclined to question its stature.

Venue: Richard Rodgers Theatre, New York (runs through March 30)
Cast: Scarlett Johansson, Ciaran Hinds, Benjamin Walker, Debra Monk, Emily Bergl, Michael Parks, Vin Knight, Brian Reddy, Jordan Dean, Tanya Birl, Will Cobbs, Lance Roberts, Cherene Snow, Laurel Griggs, Victoria Leigh, Charlotte Rose Masi, George Porteous, Noah Unger
Director: Rob Ashford
Playwright: Tennessee Williams
Set designer: Christopher Oram
Costume designer: Julie Weiss
Lighting designer: Neil Austin
Music & sound designer: Adam Cork
Presented by Stuart Thompson, Jon B. Platt, The Araca Group, Roger Berlind, Scott M. Delman, Roy Furman, Ruth Hendel, Carl Moellenberg, Scott & Brian Zeilinger, Nederlander Presentations, Tulchin/Bartner Productions, Scott Rudin